How wills went from church courts to webcams
The story of the last will and testament, from the Statute of Wills of 1540 through the Wills Act 1837 to the rules in use today, plus one video of odd wills.
On this page
The king owned the fields, the church owned your soul
For most of medieval English history you could not leave inherited land to anyone by will 1. Land was held of the king, and only land you had bought, or held for a fixed term of years, could be handed on freely by a written wish 1. An act of 1540 cracked that open 3. Nearly three centuries later a second act arrived that still houses the signing rules used in England today, and across the Atlantic the court process that proves a will is still called probate 347.
Below: the act of 1540, the act of 1837 that holds the signing rules, the church courts that handled wills until 1858, and a few famous documents along the way 35. It is history, not guidance about any particular will.
The problem the Statute of Wills fixed
Landowners had found a workaround for the no-land rule: a legal device called a feoffment to uses, with the will saying who should benefit 2. The Statute of Uses of 1535 took that power away, and a legal history prize citation reproduced by the Cambridge Faculty of Law describes the reaction as strong and fast 2. Five years later came 32 Henry VIII, chapter 1, which the statute books list as "An Act how Lands may be willed by Testament" 3.
The new act let a person devise all land held in socage and two thirds of land held by knight service, two kinds of land tenure, while the remaining third passed automatically to the heir at law 1. Freedom to leave almost all heritable land by will only arrived in 1660, with a narrow exception for land held in serjeanty 1. The drafting may not have been crystal clear: in 1542 a second act appeared whose title says it exists to explain the Statute of Wills 3.
Will or testament? Two documents in one
The phrase "last will and testament" is not just lawyers being wordy. After 1540 the will dealt with land, while the testament dealt with movable goods such as money, household goods, plate, cattle and crops 1. In practice people wrote both into one mixed document, which is why the word "will" has long covered the whole thing 1.
Why were church courts involved at all? The church had been granting probate since the early 13th century, and by the 1340s English law treated that as settled custom 1. A person's goods paid for religious bequests, mortuaries and burial instructions, which touched the soul, so the church claimed them 1. Land was a different matter: because of feudal land tenure it could not be bequeathed in the same way, so inheritance of land was not a moral matter for the church courts to police 1. Even so, because people wrote will and testament as one document, in practice the church court ended up validating the wishes for the whole estate and filing the combined document in its registry 1.
That arrangement lasted a long time. Church courts, along with other courts, kept proving wills right up to 12 January 1858 5. The Prerogative Court of Canterbury took the wealthier cases, mainly from southern England and the greater part of Wales 5. Before 1733 the probate clauses were in Latin, with one gap: during the Interregnum of 1651 to 1660 the clerks used English 5. The registered copies kept by the Prerogative Court of Canterbury average about a page, though some stop at five lines and others go past 20 pages 5.
Shakespeare's famous bed
The National Archives holds the wills of 102 famous people in a series called PROB 1, dating from the 16th to the 19th centuries, among them William Shakespeare, Admiral Lord Nelson and Jane Austen 6. Shakespeare's will is dated 25 March 1616, under a month before his death on 23 April 1616 6. It leaves gifts to fellow actors and to neighbours back in Stratford, plus the famous gift to his wife of one particular bed, not the household's finest 6. Only six examples of his signature survive, and three of them are on this one document 6.
Nelson's is filed together with a private diary covering September and October 1805 6. A few of the wills, Jane Austen's among them, are backed by affidavits in which witnesses swore the document was genuine 6.
From 1837 to webcams
A major rewrite came in 1837, with the act known today as the Wills Act 1837 34. Section 9, as it reads today, says a will is only valid if it is written down and signed by the testator, or signed for them by someone else in their presence and by their direction 4. The testator signs, or acknowledges an existing signature, with two or more witnesses watching together, and each witness then signs or acknowledges in front of the testator 4. No set wording for the attestation is required 4.
Then a pandemic met a Victorian statute. An order from 2020 with "Coronavirus" in its title added a new subsection: for wills made on or after 31 January 2020, and for a temporary window that has since closed, "presence" could mean being there by videoconference or a similar visual link 4. The section applies to England, Wales and Northern Ireland, and legislation.gov.uk warns that its revised text may lag behind the latest changes 4.
What survives across the Atlantic
In the United States, the court process that proves whether a document is a valid will is called probate 7. Cornell's Legal Information Institute explains that a valid will has to be duly executed, meaning it meets the jurisdiction's statutory requirements, such as being signed 7. Some jurisdictions allow limited flexibility through doctrines like the harmless error rule 7.
One idea lives on in some US states: the unwitnessed will written and signed in the testator's own handwriting, known as a holographic will 8. Some states and jurisdictions do not recognize them, and the requirements vary according to state law 8. Texas wants the whole document handwritten by the testator, while Utah accepts one when the signature and material portions are handwritten 8. Rules like these differ from state to state and change over time, which is why this site keeps a separate page for each state, such as Texas will requirements.
Worth watching: a list of unusual wills
Mental Floss's List Show episode on unusual wills runs through odd wishes left behind by celebrities and historical figures, the kind of bequests that make the formal rules above feel very human. It pairs well with this story.
Where to go next
In the US, signing requirements vary according to state law, and how to sign a will sets out what each state's statute asks for 8.
Shakespeare left actors, neighbours and a bed. Today an estate also includes email accounts, photos and online balances, which is what the digital assets in a will guide covers.
For the state-by-state detail behind the holographic will example above, the Texas will requirements page explains what the Texas Estates Code expects.
Sources
Keep reading
We may be paid when you use partner links on this page. How we make money